New tyre been left flat-Will it have a flat spot?

New tyre (Falken 452 225/40/18) fitted by mobile fitter. Car driven 2.5m then stood for 20 hrs before noticing that one of the tyres was actually flat.
I inflated the tyre and realised that it had a faulty valve which would hold pressure for only a couple of minutes at the most.
The fitter suggested I mess with the valve myself!

I refused and insisted I have a new tyre & valve fitted at their cost.
Am I within my rights to ask for a new tyre?

I believe damage will have been made to the tyre while being driven/stood flat.

Asked on 5 October 2011 by dp1

Answered by Honest John
You don't know that you need a new tyre. Only a new valve.
Similar questions
I have recently purchased a BMW 118d cabriolet on sensible 16-inch wheels with 205 55 16 tyres. These are not run flats but I do not trust the tyre repair and inflation kit to work and know that you have...
Can you tell me what the speed ratings mean on a set of tyres?
I have a 2015 Renault Clio with approx 18 months warranty remaining. I've had persistent trouble with the tyre sensors malfunctioning and have had three new tyres already. The dealer says it's a fault...